| Year |
Production |
Award |
Nominee |
| 2011 |
The Constant Wife |
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play |
Sarah Caldwell |
| The Constant Wife |
Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play |
Lynda Dickson |
| The Constant Wife |
Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play |
Laurie Hardy |
| The Curious Savage |
Outstanding Stage Management |
Crystal Coddington |
| A Christmas Story |
Outstanding Youth Actor in a Play |
| Thomas Sarles |  |
|
| A Christmas Story |
Outstanding Youth Actor in a Play |
Tyler Vrabel |
| A Christmas Story |
Outstanding Stage Management |
Katie McGillick |
| A Christmas Story |
Outstanding Costume Design for a Play |
The Cast |
| A Christmas Story |
Outstanding Properties for a Play |
Scott Brandt, Amy Levine, and Greg Murphy |
| The Boys Next Door |
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play |
Peter Reimann |
| |
| 2010 |
And Then There Were None |
Outstanding Stage Management in a Play |
| Crystal Coddington | |
|
| One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest |
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play |
James Houston |
| |
|
|
|
| 2009 |
Angel Street |
Outstanding Ensemble Actress in a Play |
Teresa Von den Steinen |
| Plaza Suite |
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play |
Tracey Fama |
| Plaza Suite |
Outstanding Scenic Design of a Play |
Linda Giordano & Larky Barnes |
| The Odd Couple (Female Version) |
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play |
Rupert Ravens |
| The Best Christmas Pageant Ever |
Outstanding Youth Actor in a Play |
| Tommy Kouten | |
|
| The Best Christmas Pageant Ever |
Outstanding Youth Actress in a Play |
Jaylon Kurt |
| The Best Christmas Pageant Ever |
Outstanding Youth Actress in a Play |
| Caroline Scott | |
|
| The Best Christmas Pageant Ever |
Outstanding Youth Actress in a Play |
Katie Woltornist |
| The Best Christmas Pageant Ever |
Outstanding Stage Management of a Play |
Harriet Trainor |
| |
|
|
| 2008 |
| Twilight of the Golds |
Outstanding Stage Management of a Play |
Harriet Trainor |
| |
|
|
|
| 2007 |
Extreme Unction |
Outstanding Production of an Original Play |
Anthony Neri |
| Mr. Hobb's Vacation |
Outstanding Ensemble Actress in a Play |
Kelsey Burke |
| Pippin |
Outstanding Ensemble Actress in a Musical |
Jennifer Guhl |
| Stalag 17 |
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play |
| John Pizzigoni | |
|
| Stalag 17 |
Outstanding Direction of a Play |
Roy Barry & Danielle Barry |
| Stalag 17 |
Outstanding Set Design for a Play |
Roy Barry & Larky Barnes |
| Stalag 17 |
Outstanding Lighting Design for a Play |
Dominick Abbatiello III |
| Stalag 17 |
Outstanding Costume Design for a Play |
Roy Barry & Danielle Barry |
| |
|
|
|
| 2006 |
Gypsy |
Outstanding Ensemble Actress in a Musical |
Tamara Nazarete |
| M*A*S*H |
Outstanding Ensemble Actress in a Play |
Anne Marie Zucchi |
| M*A*S*H |
Outstanding Costume Design for a Play |
Debra Schulze |
| Old Money |
Outstanding Production of an Original Play |
Thomas C. Riti |
| Old Money |
Outstanding Youth Actress in a Play |
Sarita Rosenstock |
| The Homecoming |
Outstanding Production of an Original Play |
Anthony Neri |
| The Homecoming |
Outstanding Youth Actor in a Play |
| Zach Berteletti | |
|
| The Homecoming |
Outstanding Youth Actor in a Play |
Eric Hosman |
| The Homecoming |
Outstanding Youth Actor in a Play |
Tommy Kouten |
| The Homecoming |
Outstanding Youth Actor in a Play |
Jacob-Mercer Pontier |
| |
|
|
|
| 2005 |
SVP Theatre |
Community Theater of the Year |
| SVP Theatre | |
|
| Agnes of God |
Outstanding Scenic Design of a Play |
Linda Neri |
| The Foreigner |
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play |
Joe Ross |
| Toyland |
Outstanding Production of an Original Musical |
Anthony Neri |
| |
|
|
|
| 2004 |
Don't Drink the Water |
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play |
Michael Sundberg |
| Don't Drink the Water |
Outstanding Ensemble Actress in a Play |
Debbie Glick |
| Miracle Worker |
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play |
Lisa Alford |
| WIT |
Outstanding Direction of a Play |
Linda Giordano |
| WIT |
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play |
| Terri Sturtevant | |
|
| WIT |
Outstanding Properties for a Play |
Linda Giordano & Jonathan Wierzbicki |
| |
|
|
|
| 2003 |
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof |
Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play |
Barbara Neff |
| Heaven Can Wait |
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play |
Joseph Porter |
| |
|
|
|
| 2002 |
Social Security |
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play |
David Hampson |
| Social Security |
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play |
Alison Byrne |
| Social Security |
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play |
Thomas C. Riti |
| Social Security |
Outstanding Set Design for a Play |
Jeff Dworkin & Linda Giordano |
| The Odd Couple |
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play |
| Robert Chiavaroli | |
|
| The Odd Couple |
Outstanding Ensemble Actor in a Play |
Larky Barnes |
| The Odd Couple |
Outstanding Ensemble Actress in a Play |
Heather Giarrusso |
| |
|
|
|
| 2001 |
Grease |
Outstanding Ensemble Actor in a Musical |
James Fiorello |
| |
|
|
|
| 2000 |
Grapes of Wrath |
Outstanding Direction of a Play |
Tony Adase |
| Grapes of Wrath |
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play |
Erick Roy |
| Grapes of Wrath |
Outstanding Ensemble Actress in a Play |
Cindy Keller |
| Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat |
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical |
Trent Van Doren |
| Lovers & Other Strangers |
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play |
| Stephanie Petersen | |
|
| Mr. Roberts |
Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play |
Howard Berkowitz |
| Mr. Roberts |
Outstanding Ensemble Actor in a Play |
| Tom Prickett | |
|
| Mr. Roberts |
Outstanding Set Design for a Play |
Tom Rowe |
| Mr. Roberts |
Outstanding Costume Design for a Play |
Marian Pach |
| |
|
|
|
| 1999 |
To Kill a Mockingbird |
Outstanding Ensemble Actor in a Play |
| Arnie Chinich | |
|
